As I noted
in the October 2026 blog, Our
Han Moo Kwan Club’s Lineage, Han Moo Kwan’s lineage (meaning where the Masters
of the art form received their training) stems from Shotokan and Shotokan
lineage is from Shorin-ryu Okinawan Karate.
Why does it
matter?
For one, if
discussing Han Moo Kwan with other martial artists and describing the art form,
it helps clarify why our style does not look like other Taekwondo styles (e.g.,
World Taekwondo (formally known as World Taekwondo Federation) or International
Taekwon-do) and why the forms are very different. And it helps explain why our style and forms (hyung)
are more similar (but not exact) to traditional Shotokan Karate, Shorin-ryu Okinawan
Karate and Modern Tang Soo Do.
- For more information on the history of World Taekwondo, please
refer to the two-part blog series from October and November 2015, WTF
Compared to HMK (Part I of II) and
WTF
Compared to HMK (Part II of II).
- For more information on the history of International Taekwon-do,
please refer to the two-part blog series from April and May 2016,
ITF
Compared to HMK (Part I of II) and ITF
Compared to HMK (Part II of II).
- For more information on the history of Modern Tang Soo Do, please
refer to the two-part blog series from June and July 2026,
Modern-day Tang Soo Do Compared to HMK (Part I of II) and Modern-day
Tang Soo Do Compared to HMK (Part II of II).
Second, if
talking to someone who has no experience but may have watched the Olympics or
other Taekwondo competitions, it could help clarify our Taekwondo style versus
what they may think Taekwondo looks like and is about.
And, given our
lineage, by studying videos, books, articles, etc. of Masters of Okinawan
Karate (specifically Shorin-Ryu) and Shotokan that have tried to stay true to
the original teachings, it can help provide additional details and understanding
about the techniques and especially applications in the forms.
In
addition, when researching or reviewing video from various styles, you start to
understand and recognize changes that may have been made over the years. And if the changes were intentional, this can
also lead to other insights into an art form and potentially a deeper
understanding of the differences even if the art started from a similar lineage.
For
example, Gichin Funakoshi intentionally modified the philosophy and techniques
from what he learned from his Masters in Okinawan Karate. Some examples of major changes include:
- Master
Funakoshi believed karate was to be used for more than just combat /
self-defense and referred to karate as karate-do (“the way of karate”) and
elevated it from a combat art to a life philosophy.
- Master
Funakohi, in his attempt to make karate available to everyone and taught
in public schools simplified some of the techniques. In his autobiography “Karate-do My Way
of Life”, he states, “Hoping to see karate included in the universal
physical education taught in our public schools. I set about revising the
kata so as to make them as simple as possible. … What is most important is
that karate, as a form of sport used in physical education, should be
simple enough to be practiced without undue difficulty by everybody, young
and old, boys and girls, men and women.
- Master
Funakoshi who learned both the Shorin-ryu and Shorei-ryu styles of
Okinawan karate adopted from each ryu (school). He stated in his autobiography
“Karate-do My Wy of Life”, “What we do know is that the techniques of the
Shorei School were best suited to a person with a large body, while Shorin
techniques suited people with a smaller frame and less strength. Both
schools had their advantages and disadvantages. Shõrei, for example,
taught a more effective form of self-defense, but it lacked the mobility
of the Shõrin. Karate techniques of the present day have adopted the best
qualities of both schools.”
Gichin
Funakoshi’s son, Gigō Funakoshi, who
also studied kendo and Iaido changed the art form (with Master Gichin
Funakoshi’s approval) to include longer, deeper stances, additional kicks, lifting
of the knee as high as possible before kicking, and more emphasis and training
in free sparring, among other things [Ref. 2 and 3]. The deeper, longer stances and the higher
kicks were to support building more muscle and stronger legs.
Understanding the lineage, the
original intent, any changes and rationale for the changes, reviewing videos /
reading books of Masters from the lineage can lead to a better understanding of
the art form one is studying.
Regards,
Kelly
“Even
in the forty years that I have been practicing Karate, the changes have been
many. It would be interesting to be able to go back in time, to the point when
the kata were created, and study them.” ~ Shigeru Egami (1912-1987),
Japanese master of Shotokan karate (disciple of Gichin Funakoshi) who led the Shōtōkai
association that was. Shōtōkai is a
traditionalist Japanese karate association who adheres to the original
teachings and philosophy of its founder, Gichin Funakoshi, versus the more
sports style of competitive Shotokan style emphasized under the Japan Karate
Association (JKA).
References:
2. Yoshitaka/Gigo Funakoshi, karate genius, Retrieved 10/27/2026
3. Karate - Gigo (Yoshitaka) Funakoshi (1906-1945)
No comments:
Post a Comment