Note: This is Part II of a two-part series to
discuss the similarities and differences of Modern-day (post kwans unification)
Tang Soo Do (specifically World Tang Soo Do Association) to Han Moo Kwan Tae
Kwon Do. In the first part posted in
July 2026, the comparison was on the history, focus, and techniques. In this second part the comparison will be on
sparring, forms (hyung), and ranking. All
the information contained here is based on the author’s own research of the
history of Modern-day Tang Soo Do using sources believed to be reliable;
however, absolute accuracy cannot be guaranteed. This author has done her best to state facts
and where there are opinions or educated guesses, the author has noted as
such. If the author misinterpreted
information from the sources, it was not done intentionally.
As noted in Part I of this series, while there are several Modern-day Tang Soo Do organizations out there, for the sake of this blog I will compare Han Moo Kwan against World Tang Soo Do Association (WTSDA), which is one of the largest in the United States and has a clear direct lineage to Grandmaster Hwang Kee, a founder of one of the original kwans.
1.
Sparring
In order to objectively judge / score matches as well as safety reasons, techniques and permitted striking areas are limited in WTSDA [Ref. 2].
The following are permitted areas (targets) in WTSDA:
·
Front and sides of the body
above the belt and below the neck for hand and feet techniques
· Front and side of the head and throat area are permitted for feet techniques
The following techniques are permitted in WTSDA:
·
Reverse punch, side punch, and
front hand lunge punch
· Any kicking technique to valid target area.
And the following are prohibited acts in WTSDA:
·
Throwing / sweeping
·
Pushing techniques
·
Face contact
·
Grabbing / holding
·
Vital targets
· Following techniques: boxing jab, hook, uppercut and cross punches. Use of head, Elbows, back wrist, fingers, spear hand, ridge hand, knee, toes and knife hand
When we spar in Han Moo Kwan, we only limit the use of open hand techniques with lower rank students (such as ridge hand and knife hand) until students demonstrate they can effectively use those techniques. For upper rank students, all techniques, all parts of the body (head, shoulder, elbows, forearms, hands, knees, legs, feet, etc.) are considered valid and acceptable weapons.
We also do limit the permitted area (targets) to some extent very similar to Tang Soo Do and have a couple prohibited acts (more for intermediates than advanced students until students demonstrate the control required). Those permitted areas (targets) are in place to ensure the safety of our students. For safety reasons, we do not allow intermediates students to strike towards their head until they show control. Due to the weakness of the knees/groin, we do not permit students to strike each other’s knees or groin. In addition, at the Intermediates level we limit attacking fallen opponents and grabbing opponents.
For advanced students as we practice combat (separate from exchange sparring) which promotes continuing an assault until the opponent is disabled (or the referee determines sufficient damage has occurred) we also allow strikes toward the head, practice checking the knee in a controlled manner demonstrating significant damage could have occurred because the knee was left at risk , attacking fallen opponents, grabbing if it is safe and effective, takedowns / sweeps, etc.
From a Han Moo Kwan perspective where the focus on self-defense and sparring is a form of self-defense (for more information on my views of sparring versus self-defense, please read my October 2009 blog, “Sparring vs Self Defense”, limitation of techniques, target areas, etc. limits a person’s effectiveness to defend themselves. So, for any reason other than safety, if you are training for self-defense purposes, I believe you should minimize any limitations of techniques (weapons) or permitted areas (targets). This also teaches a strong focus on not leaving vulnerable areas at risk (e.g., knees), something the sport styles neglect.
2.
Forms (Hyung)
Some Tang Soo Do schools from different organizations have over 20 forms. WTSDA has 18 forms [Ref. 2] although all schools under WTSDA may not practice all 18 or may practice more than the ones listed below. Several of these hyung are similar to Han Moo Kwan as they have similar origins as Grandmaster Hwang Kee studied (through direct training and /or self-study depending on the reference) Okinawan Karate and early Shotokan Karate as well as Kung Fu and Yang-style Taijiquan. Mr. Ui Jung Kim’s master and founder of Han Moo Kwan, Mr. Lee Kyo Yoon, learned primarily from Mr. Chun Sang Sup (founder of Yun Moo Kwan) who studied both Judo and Shotokan karate in Japan. Therefore both styles have forms that are similar to their equivalences in Shotokan and Okinawan Karate.
A comparison is below (including Shotokan most of the name differences are due to translation and what language they are in (i.e., Japanese or Korean or a translation from one language to another) and note that this does not mean the hyung are exactly the same. There are differences due to differences in how individual techniques are executed as well as some differences in interpretations / execution of the forms. This also does not mean the hyung are taught in the same order as Han Moo Kwan where there are equivalents or what forms are expected to be known at the equivalent levels / ranks.
According to the WTSDA Rulebook [Ref. 2], performance of hyung are based on the following criteria: understanding of the hyung, skill of hyung execution, degree of perfection, degree of difficulty in performing hyung, contestant’s attitude, rhythm and feeling put into the hyung, speed and coordination of the techniques, balance, power, and focus. This information along with videos and other websites reviewed that discuss applications with the hyung, leads me to believe the intent of studying and practicing hyung have many similarities to why we practice hyung in Han Moo Kwan. With all that said, Modern-day Tang Soo Do organizations like WTSDA, and the books available and videos can lead to insights into context and applications in the Han Moo Kwan techniques and forms.
3.
Ranking
Modern-day Tang Soo Do organizations have anywhere from six (6) to eight (8) colored belts levels and if you include stripes, it works out to be 2-3 times that number of levels. WTSDA has the following six (6) belt colors: White Belt, Orange, Green, Brown, and Red, and Black with stripes for sublevels.
HMK has six (6) belt levels (five different belt colors and one which has a stripe (White, Green, Blue, Brown, Brown with a black stripe (Interim Black belt), Black Belt). When the Sunnyvale HMK Club was founded, the founders were adamant that we limit the number of belt colors.
For more details on
the history of belts and rankings please read the June 2012 blog, History of Belts and Rankings.
Many Modern-day Tang Soo Do organizations such as WTSDA are also
traditional art forms for self-defense and betterment and have many
similarities to Han Moo Kwan. I believe,
though, that for schools that also focus on competitions it will lead to some
differences that I think could detract from a purer self-defense-based art form
like Han Moo Kwan.
Regards,
Kelly
"Mental and spiritual discipline are very important
aspects of Martial Arts. The Martial way
should be preserved." ~ Grandmaster Hwang Kee (1914-2002),
founder of Moo Duk Kwan, one of the five original kwans
References:
1.
World
Tang Soo Do Website, Retrieved 5/3/2026
2.
2022WTSDARulebook.pdf, Retrieved 5/3/2026
3.
Karate-Do Kyohan, The Master Text by Gichin Funakoshi
4.
Han Moo Kwan Association Hyung Reference webpage, http://www.hanmookwan.org/hyung.htm