Thursday, May 1, 2025

It Depends --- Chief Instructor's Blog May 2025

 

When I have been asked what to do when grabbed a certain way… my first answer most likely is, it depends.

When I have been asked what this technique in a form is good for… my first answer might be, it depends.

While it may be frustrating that there is not a black or answer, the reality is there is no black or answer for general questions like the two above when it comes to a self-defense martial art.

This is because it all depends on the scenario and what your intent is.

For example, what you may do, may be different in the following scenarios if approached:

·         You feel you can talk your way out of an altercation

·         You have an escape route versus not

·         Are you injured or have a limb that is not usable (e.g., broken arm)?

·         Does the assailant have a weapon or not?

·         Does the assailant seem trained?

·         You are alone versus with a loved one who is an adult

·         You are alone verses with a loved one who is a child

·         You are in an open area with many other people around or it’s a one-on-one or a one-on-several situation

·         You feel your life is being threatened

·         You feel your loved one’s life is being threatened

·         It is day time versus night time in a dark area

And the above is not an exhausted set of scenarios.  And how you react, what technique you use, what your second techniques you might use is all dependent on the scenario.  There is no one answer.  And for each of us, how we respond may be different even for the same scenario.  For someone who is a fast runner they may feel they escape certain situations more than a slower runner.

Your intent will also determine how you want to use a technique:

·         Do you want to escape the grab?

·         Do you want to trap the grab?

·         Do you want to deflect?

·         Do you want to damage?

·         What is your target?

For example, a hook punch can be thrown to escape a same side grab, punch kidneys or ribs close in, it can be thrown more like a forearm strike to damage the sternum, with a turn can be used as a takedown.

So, there is no one answer, and it just depends.

And the best way to determine for you what that “it depends” is, is to role play.  You can role play by:

·         Going through scenarios and thinking through what you may do

·         While watching fights from videos. TV shows, movies and thinking through what you may do

·         While practicing with a partner, from the same grab or attack, go through various scenarios or how you want to use the technique and practice

I highly encourage if you are not already, add role playing or more role playing in your practice to be prepared for whatever the situation may be.

 

Regards,

Kelly

 

"To be prepared for war is the most effective means of maintaining peace." ~ George Washington (1732-1799), Founding Father and the first president of the United States